Macroeconomics and financial marketsModule 4, lesson 15 of 16
Corporate earnings seasons
When Indian companies report results, how estimates and guidance are used, how to read results and earnings calls, and why a beat is not a good quarter.
In this lesson
- Describe when and how Indian listed companies report quarterly results.
- Read a results announcement for revenue, margins, one-off items and segments.
- Explain how analyst estimates and management guidance are used, and how estimates can be lowered before results.
- Explain why beating estimates does not by itself mean a good quarter.
Builds on
- Expectations and surprisesResults move prices relative to the expectations explained there.
On this page
In simple terms
Listed companies in India report their financial results every quarter. Because they all report within set periods after each quarter ends, results arrive in waves known as earnings seasons. During these weeks, many share prices move sharply as investors compare results with expectations.
When companies report
India's financial year runs from April to March, so quarters end in June, September, December and March. SEBI's listing rules set how soon after each quarter companies must publish results, with a longer period for the full-year results. The exact deadlines are in the rules and can change.
Companies announce results through the stock exchanges, along with the board meeting outcome, and often a press release and an investor presentation. Large companies usually report earlier in the season; many smaller ones near the deadline.
Reading a results announcement
Look past the headline profit:
- Revenue growth: how much came from volumes, prices, or acquisitions?
- Margins: did operating profit grow faster or slower than revenue, and why?
- One-off items: exceptional gains or losses, tax changes, write-backs. Remove them to see the underlying trend, as the quality of earnings lesson explains.
- Segments: which businesses drove the result?
- Standalone and consolidated figures: consolidated results include subsidiaries and are usually the better guide to the whole group.
- Comparisons: compare with the same quarter last year to remove seasonal effects, and with the previous quarter to see the latest direction, as the growth lesson explains.
Estimates and guidance
Analyst estimates. Analysts publish forecasts, and data providers average them into a consensus, as the expectations lesson explains. Estimates are often revised during the quarter, frequently downwards as problems become visible.
Worked example: A lowered bar
| Profit estimate three months before results | ₹500 crore |
|---|---|
| Estimate just before results | ₹420 crore |
| Actual profit | ₹440 crore |
| Against the final estimate | about 5% better |
| Against the earlier estimate | 12% worse |
Headlines report a "beat", but the quarter was weaker than investors expected a few months earlier.
Guidance. Some companies give formal guidance on revenue or margins; many in India prefer qualitative comments. Changes in guidance, or in the tone of comments, can move prices more than the quarter's numbers.
Earnings calls
After results, many companies hold earnings calls where management presents the results and answers analysts' questions. Recordings and transcripts are often published on the company's website and the exchanges. Useful things to listen for:
- Comments on demand, pricing and costs for the coming quarters.
- Answers to difficult questions, and questions that are avoided.
- Consistency with what management said in earlier calls.
The earnings cycle across the economy
Adding up results across many companies shows the earnings cycle: how the total profits of listed companies are growing or shrinking. Index-level earnings growth, compared with the index's level, gives its P/E ratio. Earnings tend to grow fastest in economic expansions and fall in slowdowns, especially for cyclical industries, as the economy and industries lesson explains.
Why it matters
Quarterly results are the most regular and detailed information investors get. Reading them carefully, past the headline and against the right comparisons, reveals how a business is really doing and guards against being misled by a "beat" or a "record".
Limitations
One quarter is a short period, and many businesses are seasonal or lumpy. Accounting choices, one-off items and acquisitions can distort comparisons. Consensus figures depend on which analysts are included.
Common mistakes
- Reacting to the headline profit without reading the details.
- Comparing with the previous quarter for a seasonal business.
- Treating a beat as proof of a good quarter.
- Ignoring the earnings call and management's outlook.
Try it yourself
- Download a company's latest quarterly results from the exchange website.
- Compare revenue, operating profit and net profit with the same quarter last year and with the previous quarter.
- Find and remove any one-off items, and recalculate the profit growth.
- Read or listen to the earnings call and note three comments about the outlook.
Key takeaways
- Indian listed companies publish results every quarter within periods set by SEBI's listing rules, so results cluster in "earnings seasons" in the weeks after each quarter ends.
- Read past the headline. Check revenue growth, margins, one-off items, segment results, and whether figures are standalone or consolidated.
- Compare with the same quarter last year to remove seasonal effects, and with the previous quarter to see the latest trend.
- Analysts' estimates are often lowered before results, so a "beat" can still mean a weaker quarter than once expected.
- Earnings calls and management commentary about demand, costs and plans often matter more than the past quarter's numbers.
Check your understanding
Finished reading?
Your progress is saved only in this browser.
Terms used in this lesson
- Earnings season
- The weeks after each quarter ends when most listed companies publish their quarterly results.
- Consensus estimate
- The average of analysts' forecasts for a company's revenue, profit or earnings per share, or of economists' forecasts for a data release.
- Earnings call
- A call held after results, in which management presents the results and answers analysts' questions.
Spotted a mistake or something unclear? Report it by email. Here is how corrections work.
This lesson is general education, not investment advice. Examples use made-up or clearly dated figures to explain ideas; they are not recommendations. Read the disclaimer.